Nephew regarded as son pleads guilty in severe neglect case of Zanesville woman


By Christine Holmes, News Director

A Zanesville man changed his plea in common pleas court this week following the June 20 death of his aunt in what was the worst case of elder neglect an emergency room doctor had ever seen. 

Monday afternoon, 30 year-old Dustin Burr pleaded guilty to the following charges:

  • Felonious assault, a second-degree felony
  • Failure to provide care, a fourth-degree felony
  • Theft with an elderly victim, fourth-degree felony
  • Endangering children, first-degree misdemeanor 

His girlfriend, 33 year-old Sheila Allberry, previously pleaded guilty to one second-degree felony count of felonious assault in November.

Jessica Johnston
Sheila Allberry, a pregnant mother of two children, appeared before Judge Kelly Cottrill on Nov. 13. Following her plea, Allberry returned to the bench after her plea and began crying.

The couple was originally indicted on involuntary manslaughter charges after 66 year-old Darlene Conger was found living in what police described as “horrendous” and “deplorable” conditions.

Officers were led to the home at 1430 Bluff St. after Allberry’s 5 year-old daughter was found wandering a nearby street in just a T-shirt. 

When officers approached the door, they could smell a foul odor coming from the home, Muskingum County Assistant Prosecutor Ron Welch said in court during Allberry’s November plea hearing. 

Welch said that stench was linked to the trash and rotten food within the residence.

After stepping inside, police could see Conger lying in a bed, covered with a black garbage bag.

Welch said there was an overwhelming amount of flies in the household with bugs on the walls and cockroaches and fecal matter on the floor.

When police were able to get a closer look at Conger’s condition, they could see bugs crawling on her body, eating her rotting flesh.

Welch noted that fluids were leaking from the woman’s body, and Allberry’s defense attorney, Keith Edwards, added that Conger had an open wound on her chest from a previous surgery.

In addition to an ambulance service being called, firefighters dressed in biohazard gear were needed to lift Conger from the bed before she could be taken to the hospital for medical attention.

Welch said Conger screamed as she was removed from the bed where police said she had been lying since August 2018 when she moved in with the couple.

According to Welch, Conger was “essentially glued to the bed by her skin” and the fluids seeping from her body, causing her skin to peel as she was lifted.

The garbage bag clothing Conger was wrapped in was filled with feces since the couple could no longer afford the adult diapers and eventual “animal pee pads” she once used.

However, Welch said Conger stated in an interview that she preferred using garbage bags, even though they were filled with her own feces, because it provided her warmth.

While arguing Allberry’s bond, Edwards painted a picture of poverty for Judge Kelly Cottrill to explain how Allberry arrived in the situation before the Court.

According to Edwards, Allberry had very little contact with Conger, and never wanted to live in the same home from the beginning.

Edwards explained that Conger had been living in a nursing home but wanted to move in with Burr and Allberry since she hated living in the facility.

Allberry, according to Edwards, didn’t want Conger joining them since she required a lot of medical attention that she didn’t want to take on herself.

Similar to what Welch told the Court, Edwards said Burr allowed Conger to move in so that he could collect her social security check.

Refusing to be the primary caregiver, Allberry lived upstairs and typically only communicated with Conger via Facebook messenger.

“I need water” and “I need food” were examples of the messages Edwards said Conger would send Allberry, to which Allberry would respond by sending Burr downstairs to handle.

Oftentimes, Edwards said there wasn’t much money for food, so the adults would sometimes go without meals.

When they could no longer afford diapers, Edwards said Burr began using clothing to clean Conger. Once their washing machine stopped working, garbage bags of soiled clothing began to pile up throughout the house.

According to Edwards, Allberry was making plans to remove herself and her children from the home.

Blaming it on the stress of caring for Conger, Edwards alleged Burr would drink heavily and smoke marijuana.

He would tell Conger “I’ll come take care of you after I finish this blunt,” said Edwards.

At that point, Cottrill stopped Edwards to question his ability to make arguments that they couldn’t eat when Burr was allegedly drinking and smoking weed.

When it was his turn to address bond, Welch argued that poverty wasn’t an excuse for the living conditions of the home.

“The state feels that while there were many things going on there, it goes to show that Miss Allberry was not making good decisions,” Welch said.

Welch added that the home was in such horrendous shape that hazmat suits had to be used in order to enter the house where children were living.

“The problem with what Miss Allberry did resulted in a situation that is unfathomable to many people,” Welch said.

According to Edwards, Allberry, who is due to have another child in April, has since lost custody of her two kids.

Following an argument from the defense in regards to Allberry’s bond, Cottrill agreed to amend her bond to $100,000 from $750,000. 

Allberry is currently awaiting sentencing.

Welch said the State would not argue for a sentence longer than six years at Allberry’s sentencing.

Burr remains jailed on $500,000 bond. 

“We look forward to sentencing arguments for Mr. Burr,” said defense attorney Mark Kaido during Burr’s plea hearing.